β€ŠThe Trap is Built One Reasonable Yes at a Time

Why do academic physicians keep saying yes to commitments that leave them with less time for the work and people that matter most?

In this episode of the Academic Medicine Strategy Podcast, Dr. Stacey Ishman explains how the trap of overcommitment is built one reasonable yes at a time. Drawing on her experience serving on multiple editorial boards and leadership committees, she shares how stepping back from work that no longer aligned with her priorities helped her protect her time, improve work-life integration, and continue advancing her academic career.

She also explores the unequal distribution of non-promotable work, why individual discipline is not always the answer, and how creating a personal decision-making filter can help physicians make faster, more intentional decisions about new commitments.

What You'll Learn in This Episode

  • Why reasonable requests can gradually consume the time needed for research, clinical work, and family.

  • How saying yes to too many service commitments can affect career priorities and work-life integration.

  • Why women physicians are more likely to be asked to take on non-promotable work.

  • How departments can identify and distribute low-promotability tasks more equitably.

  • How a personal decision-making filter makes it easier to say yes or no without guilt.

  • How to evaluate commitments based on your values and what matters most in your career.

Key Points:

00:00 – The Trap of Saying Yes to Everything
Why a full calendar can leave academic physicians without time or energy for the work they care about.

01:00 – When Service Commitments Take Over Your Time
Dr. Ishman shares how serving on four editorial boards and holding an associate editor role consumed more than eight hours each week.

02:00 – Recognizing When It's Time to Step Back
A new leadership opportunity helped her recognize that she could step away from commitments that no longer aligned with her priorities.

03:00 – Giving Yourself Permission to Say No
How stepping back from several editorial responsibilities created room for more meaningful work without stopping her academic advancement.

04:00 – The Trap Is Built One Reasonable Yes at a Time
Why individual requests may seem manageable until you recognize what each commitment replaces.

05:00 – The Unequal Distribution of Non-Promotable Work
Research discussed in the episode highlights how women are more frequently asked to take on low-promotability tasks and accept them more often.

06:00 – Creating a Filter for New Commitments
Why deciding what matters in advance makes it easier to respond to requests without guilt.

07:00 – Moving From Reflexive Yes to Intentional Decisions
How one physician used a personal filter to decline commitments and begin each day with her most important priority.

08:00 – Who Can Benefit From a Decision-Making Filter?
How physicians at different career stages and in different practice settings can use this approach.

09:00 – One Yes You Would Not Repeat
A practical exercise for identifying commitments that do not reflect the balance or priorities you want.

10:00 – Does Your Time Reflect Your Values?
How to evaluate trade-offs involving clinical work, research, family, and personal priorities.

11:00 – Identify Your Top Five Values
An introduction to the November 16 webinar and the values exercise that helps physicians build their decision-making filter.

12:00 – Coaching and Support for Owning Your Time
Dr. Ishman explains how the same method is used with coaching clients and within the Owning Your Time program.

Frequently Asked Questions

Why is it so hard for academic physicians to say no?

Many requests are reasonable and meaningful on their own. The difficulty comes from evaluating each request separately without considering the existing commitments and priorities it will displace.

What is non-promotable work in academic medicine?

Non-promotable work includes responsibilities that require time and effort but may not contribute meaningfully to promotion or career advancement. The episode discusses how these tasks can be distributed inequitably, particularly affecting women physicians.

How can physicians set better boundaries at work?

Physicians can start by identifying what matters most, reviewing their current commitments, and creating a decision-making filter. This makes it easier to evaluate new requests before agreeing to them.

Does saying no affect academic promotion?

Dr. Ishman's experience illustrates that stepping back from several service commitments did not prevent her from advancing. She became an associate professor and then a full professor three years later while improving her work-life integration.

What is a decision-making filter?

A decision-making filter is a set of priorities or values used to evaluate new commitments. It helps physicians make intentional decisions about what deserves their time and what they should decline.

Your Action Step

Think about one commitment you accepted this month that you would not agree to again.

Write it down, then ask yourself:

  • What did that commitment replace?

  • Did it support the work and priorities that matter most to me?

  • Would I make the same decision today?

The goal is to recognize the trade-offs behind each yes and make future decisions more intentionally.

Upcoming Webinar: Identify Your Top Five Values

Dr. Stacey Ishman is hosting a 60-minute webinar on November 16, 2026, at 7:00 PM Eastern Time.

During the webinar, you'll complete a values exercise to identify your top five values and learn how to use them to create a decision-making filter for your commitments.

A replay will be available for those who register but cannot attend live.

The registration link will be posted.

Work With Us:

If you're interested in working with Academic Medicine Strategy Group, visit www.amedsg.com to learn about our programs that help academic physicians build a clear, strategic path to promotion, research, and career advancement.

Rate, Review, and Follow:

If this episode helped you think differently about your commitments, follow the Academic Medicine Strategy Podcast and share it with a colleague who may be saying yes to too much.

If you'd like to get in touch or suggest a topic:

DM me on Instagram at @sishmancoach
Email me at [email protected]
Contact me through the website at www.amedsg.com